Reference:5514: Difference between revisions
| [checked revision] | [checked revision] |
Audit 5514 prose and catalogue claims; qualify dating, provenance and component assertions |
Fix dealer-in-prose lint errors (rule 5): remove dealer names as sentence subjects, keep as Sources citations only |
||
| Line 104: | Line 104: | ||
=== Serif and non-serif COMEX-signed (1972 to mid-1970s) === | === Serif and non-serif COMEX-signed (1972 to mid-1970s) === | ||
One documented example carries a non-serif COMEX dial on case 380xxxx, dated 1972; another shows a serif dial, also dated 1972, with a case number in the 4.0-million range. These dates are approximate; a serial boundary between the two forms remains unverified. [https://www.craftandtailored.com/products/1972-rolex-comex-submariner-ref-5514 Craft and Tailored, non-serif 5514] [https://hqmilton.com/products/1972-rolex-comex-submariner-5514-with-serif-dial HQ Milton, serif 5514] | |||
<span id="late-period-comex-matte"></span> | <span id="late-period-comex-matte"></span> | ||
| Line 141: | Line 141: | ||
* 9315 with 385 end links on Phillips’ COMEX 377 and 446. [https://www.phillips.com/detail/rolex/NY080222/153 Phillips, New York SIX, lot 153] [https://www.phillips.com/detail/rolex/90836 Phillips, Geneva TWO, lot 145] | * 9315 with 385 end links on Phillips’ COMEX 377 and 446. [https://www.phillips.com/detail/rolex/NY080222/153 Phillips, New York SIX, lot 153] [https://www.phillips.com/detail/rolex/90836 Phillips, Geneva TWO, lot 145] | ||
* 9315 with 380 end links on | * 9315 with 380 end links on the non-serif example. [https://www.craftandtailored.com/products/1972-rolex-comex-submariner-ref-5514 Craft and Tailored, non-serif 5514] | ||
* 93150 with 593 end links on Antiquorum’s COMEX 878. [https://catalog.antiquorum.swiss/en/lots/rolex-ref-5514-submariner-comex-big-numbers-lot-383-172 Antiquorum, 12 December 2025, lot 172] | * 93150 with 593 end links on Antiquorum’s COMEX 878. [https://catalog.antiquorum.swiss/en/lots/rolex-ref-5514-submariner-comex-big-numbers-lot-383-172 Antiquorum, 12 December 2025, lot 172] | ||
* A later 93150 bracelet with a K3 clasp on Bonhams’ COMEX 723. Bonhams also identifies a later bezel insert. [https://www.bonhams.com/auction/23511/lot/43/ Bonhams, 22 June 2016, lot 43] | * A later 93150 bracelet with a K3 clasp on Bonhams’ COMEX 723. Bonhams also identifies a later bezel insert. [https://www.bonhams.com/auction/23511/lot/43/ Bonhams, 22 June 2016, lot 43] | ||
Revision as of 14:06, 15 September 2026
Submariner › 5514
The 5514 is a no-date Submariner made for COMEX, the French commercial-diving company. It uses a 5513-derived steel case with a helium escape valve at 9 o’clock. Antiquorum gives the reference a 1972–1978 run, although individual catalogue dates differ. Watches survive with COMEX-signed dials, dials without the COMEX logo and Argentine Navy markings. Antiquorum, 12 November 2006, lot 323 Sotheby’s, 7 December 2023, lot 110 Christie’s, ARA 5514, lot 298
Core facts
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
| Reference | 5514 |
| Family | Submariner, no date |
| Distribution | Made for COMEX; outside the normal retail range |
| Production | 1972–1978 in Antiquorum’s 2006 chronology; see qualifications below |
| Movement | Automatic caliber 1520; auction examples list 26 jewels |
| Case | Steel, crown guards, approximately 40mm |
| Crystal | Acrylic |
| Dial depth marking | 660ft = 200m |
| Helium escape valve | At 9 o’clock |
| Caseback | 5513 inner stamps and separate external COMEX issue numbers appear on documented examples |
Specifications and distribution follow the catalogued examples below. Antiquorum, 9 December 2009, lot 373 Bonhams, 19 June 2025, lot 21
Where it sits in the line
Rolex supplied HEV-equipped 5513s before the dedicated 5514. Antiquorum’s 2006 sale included a 5513 with COMEX number 24, case 2,833,552, which it dates to autumn 1970. The reference number matters: that watch is evidence for the earlier 5513 programme. Antiquorum, 12 November 2006, lot 323
The 5514 kept the Submariner’s thinner case format. The Sea-Dweller used a thicker case and was also sold to the public. Phillips describes the 5514 as an exclusive COMEX supply. Phillips, New York SIX, lot 153
Production outline
Antiquorum’s 1972–1978 chronology is a useful outline, but it is not a factory production register. Its 2025 catalogue extends the run into the early 1980s without identifying a final-year example. Bonhams describes COMEX 233 as circa 1971 and later, with an IV.71 inner caseback and a different number engraved inside. The exact endpoints remain uncertain. Antiquorum, 12 November 2006, lot 323 Antiquorum, 12 December 2025, lot 172 Bonhams, 19 June 2025, lot 69
Sotheby’s 2021 catalogue gives roughly 150 watches. Its estimate is not backed by a factory record in the entry. Sotheby’s, 23 April 2021, lot 2140
COMEX issue-number bands
COMEX issue numbers and Rolex case serials are separate identifiers. Their dates can also differ. Bonhams dates COMEX 723 to circa 1975 but records issue to its former owner in 1977/78. Bonhams, 22 June 2016, lot 43
The auction table includes issue numbers 233, 377, 446, 717, 723, 763, 850 and 878. Those examples do not establish consecutive production batches or a date chart for every issue number.
Christie’s catalogued case 4,155,900 with “A.R.A” on the dial, for Armada de la República Argentina. Its back retained ROLEX COMEX 451 and the military number 68509-Ci. Christie’s, ARA 5514, lot 298
The same catalogue reports that 16 Argentine divers trained at COMEX in Marseille from 17 to 30 October 1977. It presents the commissioning of watches for them as an inference. The number of ARA watches made or surviving remains unverified. Christie’s, ARA 5514, lot 298
Phillips’ separate example, case 4,155,901, has a non-logo dial and both COMEX 446 and military number 68504-Ci on the back. It belongs to the Geneva Watch Auction TWO, lot 145. Phillips, Geneva TWO, lot 145
Movement notes
The documented examples use caliber 1520. Bonhams lists 26 jewels for COMEX 717 and 723, as does Sotheby’s for Maurice Bessard’s COMEX 850. These are no-date movements. Bonhams, 19 June 2025, lot 21 Bonhams, 22 June 2016, lot 43 Sotheby’s, 23 April 2021, lot 2140
See Movements for the 1520’s construction and its relationship to other 15xx calibers.
Dial map

Dial appearance needs to be read alongside the watch’s service history. A dial without the COMEX logo can be an early configuration or a later replacement, depending on the example.
Prototype "stealth" non-logo (1972)
Antiquorum’s Patrice Chemin watch, catalogued in 2009 as a 1972 5514/5513, has no COMEX dial logo. The house describes a testing batch of approximately 20 watches with COMEX engraved on the back but no issue number. Antiquorum, 9 December 2009, lot 373
The catalogue title also calls the dial “Maxi.” That label should stay attached to the lot description until its dial type and installation date can be established more precisely. Antiquorum, 9 December 2009, lot 373
Serif and non-serif COMEX-signed (1972 to mid-1970s)
One documented example carries a non-serif COMEX dial on case 380xxxx, dated 1972; another shows a serif dial, also dated 1972, with a case number in the 4.0-million range. These dates are approximate; a serial boundary between the two forms remains unverified. Craft and Tailored, non-serif 5514 HQ Milton, serif 5514
Late-period COMEX matte (mid-to-late 1970s)
COMEX 878, case 5,230,258, is a matte COMEX-dial example catalogued as 1977 by Antiquorum. It has the large external issue-number engraving usually called “Big Numbers.” Antiquorum, 12 December 2025, lot 172
Service-replacement non-logo
Sotheby’s identifies the non-logo dial on Douglas Matheson’s watch, case 4,089,906, as a replacement fitted during Rolex service. The lot included a Henry Hudson letter, 2008 service documents and correspondence from Matheson about its use during the HMS Edinburgh salvage. Sotheby’s, 7 December 2023, lot 110
Case, bezel, crystal, and crown
Helium escape valve
During saturation work, helium in a pressurised habitat can enter the watch case. As chamber pressure falls during decompression, the trapped gas may escape too slowly and force the crystal off. An automatic escape valve releases that excess pressure. Rolex explains this operating principle in its Sea-Dweller user guide. Rolex, Sea-Dweller user guide, pp. 6–7
The 5514 has its valve at 9 o’clock, a screw-down crown protected by crown guards, and a bidirectional timing bezel. The valve addresses decompression; the dial retains the Submariner’s 200m rating. Antiquorum, 9 December 2009, lot 373 Bonhams, 19 June 2025, lot 21
Caseback engraving evolution

Phillips describes two external COMEX layouts and three issue-number sizes. COMEX 377, dated circa 1975, has straight-line lettering and a medium-sized number. Antiquorum’s circa-1977 COMEX 878 has a large number. These examples do not establish a precise changeover year. Phillips, New York SIX, lot 153 Antiquorum, 12 December 2025, lot 172
Inner lids stamped 5513 occur on both the Phillips 377 and 446 examples. Their case serials are also repeated inside. Record the inner reference stamp, internal serial engraving and external issue number separately. Phillips, New York SIX, lot 153 Phillips, Geneva TWO, lot 145
Bracelets, end links, clasps, and packaging notes
Catalogued pairings include:
- 9315 with 385 end links on Phillips’ COMEX 377 and 446. Phillips, New York SIX, lot 153 Phillips, Geneva TWO, lot 145
- 9315 with 380 end links on the non-serif example. Craft and Tailored, non-serif 5514
- 93150 with 593 end links on Antiquorum’s COMEX 878. Antiquorum, 12 December 2025, lot 172
- A later 93150 bracelet with a K3 clasp on Bonhams’ COMEX 723. Bonhams also identifies a later bezel insert. Bonhams, 22 June 2016, lot 43
These are fitted components recorded at sale. Original delivery needs its own evidence. A clasp code dates the clasp, and a later bracelet does not by itself establish a Rolex service replacement.
Authentication
Start with the identifiers and documents for the individual watch. Photograph the reference and serial between the lugs, the inner lid markings, the external issue number and the valve. Compare those with dated service records and any diver’s paperwork.
The mixed markings on Colin Beard’s COMEX 233 show why this needs care: Bonhams records case 4,391,293, an IV.71 lid and an internal engraving of 773, then dates the watch as circa 1971 and later. The entry does not explain every component’s history. Its mixed markings need to be assessed with that provenance. Bonhams, 19 June 2025, lot 69
A documented service dial, as on Matheson’s watch, should be identified as such. Dial text or a caseback layout alone cannot settle originality. Sotheby’s, 7 December 2023, lot 110
Auction record

Results are reproduced as reported by the auction houses. Bonhams’ results include premium; estimates are labelled separately.
| Sale | COMEX no. / reference | Case serial | Catalogue description | Result or estimate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phillips, New York SIX, lot 153 (2022) | 377 / 5514 | 4,089,919 | Circa 1975; Henry Hudson letter and 2002 service guarantee | USD 252,000 result |
| Antiquorum, 12 November 2006, lot 323 | 24 / 5513 HEV | 2,833,552 | 1970 precursor, not reference 5514 | CHF 76,700 result |
| Antiquorum, 9 December 2009, lot 373 | Unnumbered / 5514–5513 | 3,804,841 (inferred from the catalogue comparison) | 1972; Patrice Chemin, non-logo dial | USD 72,000 result |
| Phillips, Geneva TWO, lot 145 (2015) | 446 / 5514 | 4,155,901 | 1974; non-logo dial, military number 68504-Ci | CHF 52,500 result |
| Bonhams, 17 December 2008, lot 302 | 763 / 5514 | 5,230,248 | 1976; diver’s logs and photographs | GBP 50,000–70,000 estimate |
| Bonhams, 22 June 2016, lot 43 | 723 / 5514 | 415**** | Circa 1975; issue 1977/78; later bracelet and insert | GBP 72,100, including premium |
| Bonhams, 19 June 2025, lot 21 | 717 / 5514 | 4,155,907 | Circa 1976; 93150, O8 clasp, 2012 service guarantee | GBP 63,900, including premium |
| Bonhams, 19 June 2025, lot 69 | 233 / 5514 | 4,391,293 | Circa 1971 and later; Colin Beard provenance. Saleroom notice corrects the logbook date to 1974. | GBP 25,600, including premium |
| Antiquorum, 12 December 2025, lot 172 | 878 / 5514 | 5,230,258 | 1977; Big Numbers, 93150/593, 1997 and 2009 documents | EUR 91,840 result |
| Sotheby’s, 23 April 2021, lot 2140 | 850 / 5514 | 4,462,758 | Circa 1977; Maurice Bessard identity card and service receipt | HKD 500,000–800,000 estimate |
| Sotheby’s, 7 December 2023, lot 110 | 5514 | 4,089,906 | Circa 1976; Douglas Matheson, non-logo service dial | USD 50,000–100,000 estimate |
Catalogue descriptions can contain errors. Bonhams’ COMEX 763 entry mentions a date aperture, and Sotheby’s COMEX 850 headline calls the watch a date model; both list caliber 1520. Those phrases conflict with the no-date reference. Bonhams, 17 December 2008, lot 302 Sotheby’s, 23 April 2021, lot 2140
Related references
The COMEX guide covers the wider supply programme. The 5514 also belongs to the 5xxx Submariner family. Consult Serial numbers for the distinction between case dating, issue dates and later component dates.
Sources
- Phillips, New York SIX, lot 153
- Phillips, Geneva TWO, lot 145
- Antiquorum, 12 November 2006, lot 323
- Antiquorum, 9 December 2009, lot 373
- Antiquorum, 12 December 2025, lot 172
- Bonhams, 19 June 2025, lot 69
- Bonhams, 19 June 2025, lot 21
- Bonhams, 22 June 2016, lot 43
- Bonhams, 17 December 2008, lot 302
- Sotheby’s, 23 April 2021, lot 2140
- Sotheby’s, 7 December 2023, lot 110
- Craft and Tailored, non-serif 5514
- HQ Milton, serif 5514
- Christie’s, ARA 5514, lot 298
- Rolex, Sea-Dweller user guide, pp. 6–7
